Selling Your Business? Here’s How To Get Top Dollar Without Getting Screwed

March 10, 2025by Nate Nead

So, you’re finally ready to cash out. Congratulations. You’ve built an empire—or at least a small fiefdom—and now you’re dreaming of handing over the keys in exchange for a suitcase full of cash. But before you start browsing beachfront properties, let me introduce you to the dark arts of M&A, where buyers come armed with smiles, spreadsheets, and the singular goal of paying you as little as humanly possible.

If you want to walk away with top dollar (and not spend the next decade in litigation), it’s time to get serious. This isn’t Small Business 101 anymore. Let’s dive in.

Know What You’re Really Selling (Spoiler: It’s Not Just the Balance Sheet)

Intellectual Property, Contracts, and Other Sexy Intangibles

While you’re busy polishing your P&L, smart buyers are licking their chops over the juicy stuff you’re not thinking about. Sure, revenue is nice, but proprietary technology, bulletproof contracts, exclusive supplier agreements, and defensible IP portfolios? That’s the gold standard. 

If you’re sitting on a half-baked patent application or a patchwork of verbal agreements with key partners, your valuation is already circling the drain. Prepping for a sale means scrubbing these assets until they sparkle. Lock down licenses, shore up your trademarks, and get your legal ducks in a row—or risk giving your buyer the perfect excuse to shave 20% off the purchase price.

Customer Concentration Nightmares

Let me guess—you’ve got one client responsible for 60% of your revenue, and they also happen to be your golfing buddy. That’s adorable. It’s also a flashing red light for buyers. The tighter your revenue is tied to a handful of customers, the less stable the business looks. If your buyer is going to pay a premium, they want broad, diversified, contractually locked-in revenue streams.

Otherwise, expect the conversation to quickly shift from, “We’re impressed,” to “We’re adjusting our offer to account for the existential risk of Client X ghosting us six months post-close.” Proactively address these dependencies or prepare to take a haircut.

Valuation Games: How Buyers Will Try to Lowball You and How to Make Them Regret It

The Dreaded “Adjusted EBITDA” Trap

You know what’s better than real EBITDA? Adjusted EBITDA. It’s the accounting equivalent of playing Monopoly and slipping extra cash under the table when no one’s looking. Buyers love to “normalize” your financials by stripping out non-recurring expenses—except somehow, their definition of “non-recurring” seems to include things like salaries, rent, and oxygen.

Before you find yourself nodding along while they hack away at your earnings, bring in a forensic accountant who’s been around the block. Every sneaky adjustment is a direct assault on your valuation, and if you’re not countering with equal precision, you’ll watch your sale price dissolve into thin air.

Strategic vs. Financial Buyers—Two Very Different Species of Sharks

Strategic vs. Financial Buyers

One wants your synergies. The other wants your cash flow. Strategic buyers (think competitors or complementary businesses) are looking for cost savings, market expansion, and long-term plays. Financial buyers (private equity and friends) just want to juice your margins and flip you in five years. Know which one you’re courting, because they value your business differently—and screw you over in entirely different ways.

Strategics may throw out a big number but bury you in post-closing integration hell. Financials might nickel-and-dime you on every contingency but at least tend to respect your existing management. Choose your shark wisely, and play the game accordingly.

Deal Structuring: Get Paid Now, Later, and Maybe Never?

If you thought agreeing on a price was the finish line, allow me to crush that fantasy. The structure of the deal is where dreams go to die. Cash at close is king, and anything else is a gamble you didn’t ask to play. Buyers will gleefully suggest earnouts, seller financing, and other deferred payment schemes that sound perfectly reasonable—until you realize you’re now working for free, trying to hit performance targets designed by the buyer’s 24-year-old MBA intern.

Oh, and taxes? Yeah, the IRS is waiting to gut whatever’s left. Get yourself a tax strategist who lives and breathes M&A, or expect to fork over a chunk of your payout to Uncle Sam for the privilege of selling your own business.

Due Diligence: Where Dreams (and Bad Accounting) Go to Die

Hope you love paperwork. Due diligence is the buyer’s chance to comb through every skeleton in your closet, and believe me, they will find them. Weak financial controls? Surprise tax liabilities? Lawsuits you thought were ancient history? They all resurface during diligence, and every one of them chips away at your leverage and your valuation.

The only way to win is ruthless preparation. Clean your books, resolve outstanding disputes, and have airtight documentation ready to go. If you’re scrambling to answer basic questions during diligence, the buyer will start preparing their discount requests before you’ve even finished your sentence.

The Negotiation Bloodbath: How To Win Without Burning the Whole Place Down

Buyers expect you to fight for your price. What they don’t expect is for you to do it with finesse. Show up swinging too hard, and you’ll spook them. Play too soft, and you’ll leave money on the table. The secret sauce? Tactical confidence. Know your value, anticipate their objections, and push back without turning the deal into a WWE match.

And remember, this isn’t just about numbers. It’s about ego management—yours and theirs. Flatter them, challenge them, and always, always be willing to walk away. The moment you act desperate, the vultures start circling.

Pick Your Gladiators: Why Your Deal Team Matters More Than You Think

Investment Bankers: The Good, The Bad, and The Commission-Hungry

Here’s the cold truth: a great investment banker will earn every penny of their fat commission by creating a feeding frenzy around your business. A bad one will chase the first mediocre offer and push you to accept it so they can move on to the next victim. Vet them like you’re hiring someone to defuse a bomb, because that’s effectively what they’re doing. Look for proven track records, industry expertise, and zero tolerance for BS.

Lawyers Who Kill Deals (And Those Who Save Them)

Your brother-in-law who did your will? Fire him immediately. M&A law is a blood sport, and you need a heavyweight who knows how to protect you without blowing up the deal over trivialities. The best attorneys know when to press, when to concede, and how to keep the process moving forward without setting the building on fire. If your lawyer’s goal is to win every clause, congratulations—you’re going to lose the whole thing.

Nate Nead

Nate Nead is a former licensed investment banker and Principal at InvestNet, LLC and HOLD.co. Nate works with middle-market corporate clients looking to acquire, sell and divest. Nate resides in Bentonville, Arkansas with his family where he enjoys mountain biking.