How CRTs Can Enhance After-Tax Returns in M&A Transactions

Every owner who sells a closely held company in the world of mergers and acquisitions (M&A) dreams of walking away with a life-changing check. Yet the moment that wire hits the bank, a second reality sets in: capital-gains taxes are poised to claim a sizable share.One under-utilized but powerful planning tool—especially for sellers with charitable intent—is the Charitable Remainder Trust (CRT). When properly integrated into an M&A timeline, a CRT can transform an ordinary liquidity event into a strategy that boosts spendable, after-tax proceeds while supporting the causes that matter to you.

The Capital-Gains Tax Headwind in Business Sales

A business sale often produces the single largest capital gain its owner will ever recognize. Assuming a combined federal and state rate of roughly 25%–35%, an owner who nets $10 million in gain could be writing a tax check ranging from $2.5 million to $3.5 million.That tax drag directly reduces the capital available for the next venture, retirement, or generational wealth transfer. Because a CRT is a tax-exempt entity, it allows the owner to defer—and in many cases permanently avoid—a meaningful portion of those capital-gains taxes.

How the Numbers Look Outside a CRT

  • Company is sold for $12 million.
  • Basis (original investment) is $2 million.
  • Capital gain: $10 million.
  • Taxes (assume 30% blended rate): $3 million.
  • Net available for reinvestment or personal use: $7 million.

How the Numbers Look Inside a CRT

  • Shares are transferred to a CRT before signing the definitive purchase agreement.
  • CRT sells the shares for the same $12 million and realizes the $10 million gain tax-free.
  • CRT invests the full $12 million.
  • The trust pays the grantor an income stream—usually 5%–8% of trust assets—each year for life or a term of up to 20 years.
  • Only the annual distributions, not the full gain, are taxed to the grantor as received, typically yielding both deferral and rate-reduction benefits.

CRT Fundamentals Every Seller Should Know

A CRT is an irrevocable, split-interest trust: you receive an income interest now, and one or more charities receive the remainder interest later. Under the Internal Revenue Code, the CRT itself is exempt from income tax, so it can sell appreciated assets—including closely held stock—without a tax bite.Bullet-Point Recap of CRT Basics:

  • Irrevocable trust recognized under IRC §664.
  • Two main types: Charitable Remainder Annuity Trust (CRAT) and Charitable Remainder Unitrust (CRUT).
  • Pays income to you (and optionally your spouse or other beneficiary) for life or a term of years.
  • Remaining corpus passes to charity at the trust’s termination.
  • Current-year charitable deduction equals the actuarial value of the remainder interest.
  • Annual payout must be at least 5% and not more than 50% of initial (CRAT) or annual (CRUT) trust value.

Key Parties in the Arrangement

  • Grantor/Seller: Transfers appreciated stock to the CRT.
  • Trustee: Manages the trust assets and coordinates the sale; may be the seller, a trusted advisor, or a corporate trustee.
  • Charitable Remainder Beneficiaries: One or more qualified charities ultimately receive the remaining assets.
  • Legal and Tax Advisors: Draft governing documents, review compliance, and, most importantly, ensure the transfer occurs before the sale becomes legally binding for tax purposes.

Choosing the Right Payout Structure

CRATs distribute a fixed amount each year, providing predictable cash flow but no inflation hedge. CRUTs distribute a fixed percentage of annual trust value, allowing payments to rise (or fall) with investment performance. For sellers who expect significant post-sale appreciation—think concentrated positions now diversified into a growth-oriented portfolio—a CRUT often aligns better with long-term goals.

Slotting a CRT Into the M&A Timeline

Timing is everything. The IRS scrutinizes presale CRT transfers, so you must contribute the shares before a binding obligation to sell exists. Practically, that means acting before the purchase-agreement ink is dry, typically in the window between signing a letter of intent (LOI) and executing definitive documents.Typical Implementation Milestones:

Pre-LOI Alignment

  • Discuss charitable intent, cash-flow needs, and overall estate plan with the advisory team.
  • Run comparative financial models: sale with CRT vs. sale without.

Post-LOI, Pre-Purchase Agreement

  • Engage legal counsel to draft the CRT agreement and coordinate with buyer’s counsel on share-transfer mechanics.
  • Secure trustee and decide on initial investment strategy for trust assets.

Closing and Funding

  • Transfer shares into the newly formed CRT before final purchase documents become binding.
  • CRT, as shareholder of record, signs the purchase agreement and receives sale proceeds tax-free.

Post-Closing Administration

  • Invest trust corpus according to written investment policy.
  • Begin required annual payouts and issue Form K-1 (or equivalent) to income beneficiaries for amounts distributed.

Quantifying the After-Tax Advantage

Imagine a 55-year-old owner sells a manufacturing firm and would like steady income for retirement plus a philanthropic legacy. She transfers $10 million of stock (basis $1 million) into a CRUT with a 6% payout.Key Outcomes Over a 20-Year Horizon (Assuming 6.5% average portfolio return):

  • Annual income to the seller begins at $600,000 and trends upward as the trust value grows.
  • Present-value charitable deduction at funding: roughly $1.2 million, producing immediate tax savings.
  • Total distributions to sellers over 20 years: about $14 million, of which only a fraction is taxed at higher ordinary-income rates.
  • Remainder to charity after 20 years: roughly $8 million (varies with market performance).
  • Comparative scenario, no CRT: seller pays $2.7 million in capital-gains tax up front and must earn back that lost capital before matching CRT cash flow—often an uphill climb.

The numbers illustrate why a CRT can materially improve a seller’s after-tax, spendable wealth while simultaneously fueling charitable impact.

Practical Considerations and Common Pitfalls

Before rushing to sign trust documents, keep a pragmatic checklist in mind:

  • Irrevocability: Once assets are transferred, you cannot recapture them. Ensure you are comfortable parting with the principal in exchange for an income stream.
  • Liquidity Needs: CRT payouts are statutorily bound. If you need a lump sum—for example, to purchase a beach house—you may need a separate side fund.
  • Asset Qualification: S corporations pose added complexity; C-corp or LLC interests are usually more straightforward.
  • Valuation and Escrow Issues: The IRS requires a qualified appraisal for non-marketable shares; plan for timing and cost.
  • Unitrust Rebalancing: Because CRUT payouts fluctuate, investment discipline—particularly around rebalancing after large market moves—is critical.
  • State Law Nuances: Some states have additional filing or notice requirements for charitable trusts.
  • Coordination With Estate Plan: A CRT can dovetail with gifting strategies, grantor-retained annuity trusts (GRATs), or a family foundation, but sequencing matters.

Is a CRT the Right Fit for Your Exit?

A CRT is not a magic wand; it makes the most sense for an owner who (1) holds highly appreciated equity, (2) values steady, long-term income over a one-time windfall, and (3) has genuine charitable goals. If that describes you, the next step is to convene an integrated advisory team—investment, legal, tax, and charitable—to model outcomes and navigate the procedural nuances.By weaving a Charitable Remainder Trust into your M&A playbook, you can turn what might be a run-of-the-mill liquidity event into a triple win: larger after-tax cash flow for you, a deferred (or reduced) tax bill for the IRS, and a substantial end gift to the organizations that inspire you. For many sellers, it is the rare opportunity to create a personal, familial, and philanthropic legacy in one decisive move—proof that thoughtful planning can make the financial pie materially bigger for everyone who matters.

Get in Touch With Us

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter

Get exclusive insights and analysis from our advisory team — designed to help you stay ahead of the market.

Subscribe Now